How to Become an Independent Insurance Agent

Becoming an independent insurance agent takes little more than passing the license exam to have an insurance license, but becoming a successful independent insurance agent requires much more.  Independent insurance agents typically require a strong business plan to succeed and often capital to weather fluctuating income.

Captive versus Independent Insurance Agent

Many people begin their careers in the insurance business as captive agents.  These are people who work for a specific insurance company and represent it during transactions.  The captive agent generally has sales quotas and usually must look to his/her company first for all insurance solutions.  If the company does not have a reasonable insurance product for a given potential client, the captive agent can sometimes look for products at other insurance companies and act as a broker to sell that outside product to his/her new client.

Captive agents often receive fringe benefits beyond just the commissions paid on the insurance business they produce.  This might look something like having access to health insurance at a subsidized cost or receiving reimbursement for certain business operating expenses like rent or professional liability insurance.Insurance Agent Selling

Independent insurance agents, alternatively, do not work for a specific insurance company and do not represent any insurance company.  They instead act as a broker between insurance companies and insurance buyers.

Independent agents do not generally have sales quotas at any specific company.  However, some companies may require a certain level of sales submitted annually in order to maintain a selling relationship with the independent agent.

Independent agents generally do not receive fringe benefits like captive agents.  However, independent agents do often receive expense allowance payments on the insurance business they sell for a company.  This comes as a bonus payment on top of the insurance commissions payable to the independent agent.

Reasons to Go Independent

Some captive agents transition from a career captive arrangement to an independent agent.  Common motivators for making this move are:

  • Freedom to sell products from multiple companies with no quotas to fill
  • Additional compensation through expense allowances
  • Fewer compliance roadblocks when conducting business

No Quotas

While independent agents do not have quotas, they often find it extremely difficult to maintain strong business relationships with several life insurance companies.  Each insurance company has its own unique systems while conducting and servicing insurance business and it's very difficult to manage several of these idiosyncracies across a large number of companies.

Independent agents often find it easiest to work primarily with one company while selling products from other companies on occasion.  The good news is the agent has no real worry about being fired for not meeting a sales goal.  But we should note the reality that most independent agents still act somewhat like their captive counterparts when it comes to recommending a favored company.

Additional Compensation

One of the biggest misnomers that likely exists about independent agents is that they earn more money when selling insurance than captive agents.  While there's a shred of truth to this, and for some very high producing independent agents an opportunity exists to exploit this truth, for most the compensation is roughly equal across the board.

The fringe benefits enjoyed by captive agents often equal or outweigh the additional compensation paid to an independent agent.

Compliance Roadblocks

There's no doubt that insurance company-established compliance can be a serious impediment to operating an insurance practice.  Sometimes these impediments are for good; other times they are major annoyances with varying degrees of prudence.

Independent agents can avoid many compliance roadblocks because they do not work for any specific insurance company.  There certainly are rules they must follow, but insurers are much less worried about how independent agents conduct their day-to-day business because it has little effect or consequence to the insurance company.

Transitioning from Captive to Independent

For captive agents, there isn't a formal process for becoming independent per se.  The captive agent terminates his/her employment contract with his/her employer and can at that point act as an independent agent if he/she wishes.  Sometimes, contract termination isn't at the discretion of the agent.

But while the process of transitioning isn't necessarily a formal one, there is certainly a good deal of planning recommended to the captive agent looking to make this transition.

A currently captive agent should heavily consider the benefits derived from the career insurance company.  He/she should also strongly investigate the effect of leaving a company and the process of transitioning clients (if applicable) to his/her new practice.  Some companies may make this transition extremely difficult, while others will put up few if any impediments.

Some, but definitely not all, agents will have an option to continue to sell their former career company's products after transitioning to independent agent status.  This means they will broker that business just like any business they produce once independent.  But, the agent must understand that he/she no longer works for the company and can no longer market himself/herself as a representative of the company.  Also, resources the agents may have had ready access to as a career agent may no longer be available to him/her as an independent agent.

For people who spent time as a captive agent, there's a good chance they are familiar with several aspects of business as usual when working as an insurance agent.  This might include finding and buying professional liability insurance, being responsible for income tax withholdings, and filing/paying for insurance licenses.

But there are potential aspects of being an independent insurance agent that are new to a captive agent.  Many captive agents receive advanced commissions for insurance business paid under an arrangement other than annually (monthly for example).  This means the insurance company assumes it will receive the required premium payments and pays the insurance agent ahead of receiving those actual premium payments.  This is not a common payment option for independent agents–they instead receive commissions when the policy owner pays the premium.

Starting out as an Independent Agent

Some people chose to take an insurance licensing exam and become an independent agent without working for any insurance company.  This is a bold move that can prove extremely difficult.  While there are few impediments in place to prevent someone from doing this, it is possible for some insurance companies to refuse to appoint someone newly licensed with no professional background selling insurance to sell their products–this is especially true in the home and auto insurance industry.

Additionally, someone who begins selling insurance with no prior experience will likely lack certain knowledge about industry norms that impact day-to-day business conduct.  The inexperienced agents may not realize he/she needs professional liability insurance and may very likely not know where to begin looking for it.

Starting out independent can be very overwhelming, but for those who find themselves in over their heads, there's always the option of finding a captive arrangement at a company.

9 thoughts on “How to Become an Independent Insurance Agent”

  1. This doesn’t explain anything about how to become an independent insurance agent. Thanks for wasting everyone’s time who reads this.

    • I’m not the same person but I agree. I thought it would be how to contact the insurance company to become an independent agent for them. I have my license and have no idea where to go from here. This article just explains the differences, tells you to quit your captive job and gives reassurance that you can do it. HOW do you do it? Who do I contact? What do I need besides my license?

      • So I guess our use of “Step by Step Guide” in the title misled you? ***WARNING BLATANT USE OF SARCASM***

        • Man that’s a real display of class. Being sarcastic with your readers who are commenting on your post. With so many sources on the web this will be my last visit here.

          • Pro tip: If you’re this easily offended, there’s a very high chance you’re going to struggle as an insurance agent.

  2. Thank you Brandon. As a 13 year captive agent who has left the industry for almost 2 years off, I am looking to go back to work as an Independent Agent. Your article was helpful in reassuring me the opportunity still exists. David

  3. This doesn’t show how to become. I’m P & C insured in all 50 states. Once I have my business license and insurance is there a specific place I can contact to sell multiple P&C brands?


Leave a Comment